Fish Meal
Last updated: February 10, 2026
Table of Contents
Quick Summary
Fish Meal Rendered fish (species unspecified) with moisture removed. Concentrated protein with omega-3s.
What It Is
Fish meal is a rendered, concentrated protein source made from whole fish or fish byproducts. Unlike chicken meal or beef meal, the term 'fish meal' doesn't specify which fish species are used—it can include menhaden, herring, anchovy, pollock, or various fish processing byproducts. AAFCO defines fish meal as 'the clean, dried, ground tissue of undecomposed whole fish or fish cuttings, with or without the oil extracted.' The rendering process cooks fish at high temperatures to remove moisture and separate oil (which may be sold separately as fish oil). The remaining material is dried and ground into a protein-rich powder containing 60-72% protein—higher protein concentration than chicken or beef meal. Fish meal provides not just protein but also omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA), though levels vary depending on whether oil has been extracted and which fish species were used. Fish meal is valued for its unique amino acid profile and marine-source nutrients.
Compare to Similar Ingredients
- vs. salmon meal: Salmon meal specifies the fish species (salmon), providing transparency and consistency. Salmon meal typically has higher omega-3 content and is considered premium. Generic 'fish meal' can be any fish species and quality varies more. Salmon meal is preferred for ingredient transparency, though fish meal is often more cost-effective.
- vs. chicken meal: Both are concentrated proteins (60-72% for fish meal vs 60-65% for chicken meal). Fish meal uniquely provides omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA), while chicken meal does not. Fish meal may have a stronger odor that some dogs find more appealing. Chicken meal is generally more digestible (85-90% vs 75-85% for fish meal). Fish meal costs more due to fishing industry economics.
- vs. fish oil: Fish oil is the fat extracted from fish, providing concentrated omega-3s but little protein. Fish meal is the protein-rich remainder after oil extraction, still containing some omega-3s but primarily valued for protein. Many premium foods include both fish meal (for protein) and additional fish oil (for supplemental omega-3s).
- vs. anchovy meal: Fish meal is a generic term (could be any fish species), while anchovy meal specifies anchovies. Named sources like anchovy meal are more transparent and preferable.
Why It's Used in Dog Products
Fish meal serves multiple purposes in dog food formulation. First, it provides a novel protein source for dogs with sensitivities to chicken, beef, or lamb—fish proteins are structurally different and less likely to trigger reactions in protein-sensitive dogs. Second, fish meal naturally contains omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA), which support skin health, coat quality, joint function, and cognitive function. Third, its high protein concentration (60-72%) helps achieve high-protein formulas efficiently. Fourth, fish meal provides marine-source nutrients like iodine, selenium, and specific amino acids that complement land-animal proteins. Fifth, its strong smell and flavor make it highly palatable—many dogs are attracted to fish-based foods. Sixth, fish meal is cost-effective compared to whole fish or specified fish meals like salmon meal. Finally, using fish meal can be more sustainable than overfishing specific species, though sourcing practices vary widely.
Nutritional Profile
Macronutrients
- Protein: 60-72% (higher than chicken or beef meal)
- Fat: 6-12% (varies based on whether oil was extracted)
- Moisture: 10% maximum (per AAFCO)
Key Micronutrients
- Omega3 Fatty Acids: Variable (1-3% if oil extracted, higher if not) - includes EPA and DHA
- Iodine: High levels from marine source
- Selenium: Very high - fish is excellent selenium source
- Phosphorus: High (3-4%)
- Calcium: Variable (2-6% depending on bone content)
- B Vitamins: Good source, particularly B12 and niacin
Amino Acids
- Complete amino acid profile
- High in lysine and methionine
- Unique marine-source amino acid profile
- Digestibility typically 75-85%, varies by fish species and processing
Bioavailability: Fish meal provides highly bioavailable protein, though digestibility (75-85%) is slightly lower than chicken meal due to scale and bone content. The omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA) from fish are in forms dogs can use directly, unlike plant-based omega-3s (ALA) which require conversion. Selenium and iodine from fish meal are highly bioavailable.
Quality Considerations
Fish meal quality varies enormously based on source species, processing methods, and freshness of raw material. Premium fish meal is made from whole fish (menhaden, herring, anchovies) caught specifically for feed production, processed quickly to prevent spoilage. Lower-quality fish meal may come from fish processing waste or less desirable species. The term 'fish meal' lacks transparency—'salmon meal,' 'menhaden meal,' or 'herring meal' are preferable because they specify species. Processing temperature matters: excessive heat damages omega-3 fatty acids and amino acids. Freshness is critical—fish spoils rapidly, and rancid fish meal has poor nutritional value and unpleasant smell. Geographic source indicates quality: Norwegian, Icelandic, and Alaskan fish meals often meet higher standards. Some fish meals come from sustainable fisheries (look for MSC certification), while others contribute to overfishing. Inclusion rate matters: fish meal in the first 5 ingredients indicates meaningful contribution (typically 8-15% of formula). Smell should be fishy but not putrid or ammonia-like.
Red Flags
- Generic 'fish meal' without species or source specified
- Strong ammonia or rotten smell indicating spoilage
- Listed far down ingredient list in 'fish formula'
- No information about sustainability or sourcing
- Very dark color suggesting over-processing
- Extremely cheap price suggesting low-quality byproducts
Green Flags
- Species specified: 'menhaden meal,' 'herring meal,' 'salmon meal'
- Source disclosed (wild-caught Alaska, sustainably sourced, etc.)
- MSC (Marine Stewardship Council) or similar certification
- Listed in first 5 ingredients
- Brand transparency about suppliers
- Medium brown color, distinctly fishy (not rotten) smell
Good protein but generic term. Specific fish species (salmon meal, menhaden meal) preferred for transparency.
Potential Concerns
The primary concerns with fish meal include quality variability, sourcing transparency, and environmental sustainability. Lower-quality fish meal may be made from spoiled fish or undesirable species, resulting in poor nutritional value and palatability. Generic 'fish meal' provides no transparency about species or source—it could be high-quality menhaden or low-quality fish waste. Heavy metal contamination (mercury, lead) is a potential concern with fish products, though reputable manufacturers test every batch and contamination is rare in dog food. Ethoxyquin, a controversial preservative, was historically used to preserve fish meal during shipping, though many brands now use natural alternatives. Some fish meals come from unsustainable fisheries contributing to ocean depletion. Fish allergies in dogs exist but are relatively uncommon—fish is often used as a novel protein for dogs allergic to chicken or beef. The strong fish smell may be off-putting to owners (though dogs usually love it). Omega-3 content varies dramatically depending on whether oil was extracted during processing.
Contraindications
- Dogs with confirmed fish protein allergies (though rare)
- Dogs with inflammatory conditions should ensure fish meal hasn't been overly processed (which damages omega-3s)
- Specific brand recalls or contamination issues
Life Stage Considerations: Fish meal is appropriate for all life stages when properly formulated. The omega-3 content benefits puppies' brain development and senior dogs' cognitive function. The high protein supports growth, maintenance, and muscle preservation. The calcium and phosphorus must be balanced—excessive minerals from fish meal can harm large-breed puppies. Active and working dogs benefit from the protein density and omega-3 anti-inflammatory effects.
Scientific Evidence
Fish meal has been used in animal feed for over a century and is well-studied. Research demonstrates its value as a concentrated protein source and natural provider of omega-3 fatty acids. Studies show benefits for skin health, coat quality, and cognitive function in dogs fed fish-based proteins.
Key Research Findings
- AAFCO defines fish meal as 'the clean, dried, ground tissue of undecomposed whole fish or fish cuttings, with or without the oil extracted' (AAFCO Official Publication) [Source]
- Fish meal provides EPA and DHA omega-3 fatty acids in forms directly usable by dogs, supporting skin, coat, joint, and cognitive health (Veterinary nutritional research)
Evidence Level: Well-established ingredient with extensive research supporting its nutritional value in canine diets.
How to Spot on Labels
Reading ingredient labels can be confusing. Here's how to identify and evaluate this ingredient:
What to Look For
- Look for 'Fish Meal' in the ingredient list, ideally in first 5 ingredients
- Better brands specify the fish: 'salmon meal,' 'menhaden meal,' 'herring meal'
- Check for sustainability certifications (MSC)
- May be listed with benefits: 'fish meal (a source of omega-3 fatty acids)'
Alternative Names
This ingredient may also appear as:
- Menhaden meal (specific fish meal)
- Herring meal (specific fish meal)
- Ocean fish meal (generic, like fish meal)
- White fish meal (generic, less transparent)
Typical Position: In fish-based formulas, fish meal typically appears in positions 1-5. In chicken or beef formulas, it may appear as a secondary protein source (positions 5-10) for omega-3 benefits and protein variety.
Quality protein but we prefer named fish species for ingredient transparency.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is fish meal better than chicken meal for dogs?
Neither is inherently better—they serve different purposes. Fish meal uniquely provides omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA) which support skin, coat, joint, and brain health. Chicken meal is generally more digestible (85-90% vs 75-85% for fish meal) and less likely to cause sensitivities. Fish meal is valuable as a novel protein for dogs with chicken sensitivities. The best approach is often a combination: chicken meal as the primary protein with fish meal as a secondary source for omega-3 benefits. Many premium foods include both.
What kind of fish is in fish meal?
Generic 'fish meal' doesn't specify species—it can include menhaden, herring, anchovy, pollock, whitefish, or various fish processing byproducts. The species can vary from batch to batch. This lack of transparency is why many nutritionists prefer named fish meals like 'salmon meal,' 'menhaden meal,' or 'herring meal,' which specify exactly what's included. If you want to know what fish is in your dog's food, look for named fish ingredients or contact the manufacturer directly.
Does fish meal contain mercury or heavy metals?
Fish meal can contain trace amounts of mercury and other heavy metals that accumulate in fish, but levels in dog food are typically very low and well within safety limits. Reputable manufacturers test every batch for heavy metals and contaminants. Smaller, shorter-lived fish (menhaden, herring, anchovies) accumulate less mercury than large predatory fish like tuna or swordfish. Fish meal made from these smaller species is safer. If concerned, choose brands that publish testing results or contact manufacturers to ask about their heavy metal testing protocols. Pet food regulations include maximum allowable levels for contaminants.
Is fish meal sustainable for the environment?
Sustainability varies dramatically depending on the source. Some fish meal comes from industrial fishing that contributes to ocean depletion, while other sources use fish processing byproducts that would otherwise be wasted, or come from sustainably managed fisheries. Look for fish meals certified by the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) or similar organizations. Named fish species from certified sustainable sources (like Alaskan salmon) are preferable. Some manufacturers are transparent about sourcing and sustainability—research brands and contact them to ask about their practices. Choosing named, sustainably-sourced fish meals supports better fishing practices.
Why does fish meal smell so strong?
Fish meal has a distinctive, strong odor because it's made from concentrated fish. The rendering process removes water but intensifies the natural fish smell. Fresh, quality fish meal should smell distinctly fishy but not rotten, putrid, or ammonia-like. Dogs typically find this smell highly appealing and palatable. Some owners dislike the odor, but it's not harmful. A strong ammonia smell or rotten odor indicates spoilage and poor quality. If your dog's food smells excessively unpleasant (beyond normal fish smell), contact the manufacturer—it may be a quality issue.
Does fish meal provide enough omega-3 fatty acids?
The omega-3 content in fish meal varies significantly. If oil was extracted during processing (common practice), fish meal may contain only 1-3% omega-3 fatty acids. If oil wasn't extracted, it can contain 6-10%. For significant omega-3 benefits, many premium foods include fish meal for protein plus additional fish oil for concentrated omega-3s. Check the guaranteed analysis for EPA and DHA levels. For therapeutic omega-3 supplementation (for joint issues, inflammation, skin conditions), fish oil supplements provide more controlled dosing than relying on fish meal alone.
Related Articles
Related Ingredients
Analyze Your Dog's Food
Want to know what's really in your dog's food, treats, or supplements? Paste the ingredient list to get instant analysis.
Try the Analyzer Tool