Protein for Dogs: Requirements, Quality & Best Sources
Protein is the foundation of your dog's diet—essential for muscle, organs, immune function, and overall health. But not all protein is created equal. Quality, digestibility, and source matter as much as quantity. Here's what you need to know about protein requirements, how to evaluate quality, and the best protein sources for dogs.
Protein for Dogs: Key Points
- Minimum requirement: 18% for adults, 22.5% for puppies (AAFCO)
- Optimal levels: 25-30% for most dogs, 30-40% for active/working dogs
- Quality matters more than quantity — digestibility and amino acid profile are critical
- Best sources: eggs, organ meats, muscle meats, whole fish
- Senior dogs need more protein, not less (maintains muscle mass)
- Whole-food proteins beat processed meals in bioavailability
- Plant proteins can supplement but shouldn't be primary (dogs are facultative carnivores)
How Much Protein Do Dogs Need?
The answer depends on age, activity level, and health status—but most dogs need more than minimum recommendations suggest.
AAFCO Minimum Standards:
- Adult dogs: 18% protein (dry matter basis)
- Puppies (growth): 22.5% protein
- Pregnant/nursing dogs: 22.5% protein
These are minimums—the lowest amount needed to prevent deficiency. They're not optimal for health and vitality.
Optimal Protein Levels:
| Dog Type | Recommended Protein | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Adult (moderately active) | 25-30% | Maintains muscle, supports metabolism, provides energy |
| Puppies | 25-30% | Rapid growth, tissue development, immune system building |
| Senior dogs | 25-30% | Prevents muscle loss, supports organ function, aids recovery |
| Working/athletic dogs | 30-40% | Muscle recovery, endurance, high energy demands |
| Pregnant/nursing | 28-35% | Fetal development, milk production, maternal recovery |
Dry Matter Basis: Protein percentages on dog food labels include moisture. To compare foods accurately, calculate dry matter basis: (Protein % ÷ [100 - Moisture %]) × 100. Example: Food with 24% protein and 10% moisture = (24 ÷ 90) × 100 = 26.7% protein dry matter basis.
Quality Matters More Than Quantity
A dog food with 40% protein sounds impressive—but if the protein is poorly digestible or lacks essential amino acids, your dog won't thrive. Quality is determined by several factors.
1. Biological Value (Digestibility)
Biological value measures how much of the protein your dog can actually absorb and use.
| Protein Source | Biological Value | Digestibility |
|---|---|---|
| Whole eggs | 100 | The gold standard |
| Organ meats (liver, kidney) | 90-95 | Extremely high |
| Muscle meats (chicken, beef) | 85-90 | Very high |
| Fish (salmon, sardines) | 85-90 | Very high |
| Meat meals (chicken meal) | 70-80 | Moderate (heat-damaged) |
| Plant proteins (soy, pea) | 60-75 | Lower (incomplete amino acids) |
| Rendered by-products | 50-70 | Highly variable, often poor |
What this means: A food with 25% protein from whole meats and eggs is more valuable than one with 35% protein from meat meals and plant proteins.
2. Amino Acid Profile
Protein is made of amino acids. Dogs require 10 essential amino acids they can't produce themselves:
- Arginine
- Histidine
- Isoleucine
- Leucine
- Lysine
- Methionine
- Phenylalanine
- Threonine
- Tryptophan
- Valine
Complete proteins contain all essential amino acids in adequate amounts. Animal proteins (meat, eggs, fish, dairy) are complete. Most plant proteins are incomplete—missing or low in one or more essential amino acids.
3. Processing and Heat Damage
Heat denatures proteins, reducing digestibility and destroying some amino acids.
- Fresh/frozen meats — Minimal processing, highest nutrient retention
- Freeze-dried/dehydrated — Low-heat processing, good nutrient retention
- Gently cooked — Moderate heat, some nutrient loss but still high quality
- Extruded kibble — High heat (300-400°F), significant protein denaturation
- Rendered meals — Extreme heat, pressure, significant nutrient loss
The less processing, the better the protein quality.
Best High-Protein Foods for Dogs
The highest-quality proteins are minimally processed, easily digestible, and nutrient-dense.
1. Eggs
Why they're excellent: Eggs have a biological value of 100—the perfect protein. They contain all essential amino acids in ideal ratios, are highly digestible, and provide vitamins (A, D, E, B12), minerals (selenium, iron), and healthy fats.
How to feed: Cooked (scrambled, boiled) is best for digestibility. Raw eggs are safe but contain avidin (binds biotin). 1-2 whole eggs daily for a 50 lb dog.
2. Organ Meats
Why they're excellent: Liver, kidney, and heart are the most nutrient-dense proteins available. They provide 20-25g protein per 100g plus vitamins (A, B12, folate), minerals (iron, zinc, copper), and CoQ10.
How to feed: Organ meats should make up 5-10% of your dog's diet. Feed 2-4 oz of liver, kidney, or heart 2-3x per week for a 50 lb dog. Start small—too much liver can cause loose stools.
See our organ nutrition guide for details.
3. Muscle Meats
Best options: Chicken, turkey, lean beef, lamb, venison.
Why they're excellent: Muscle meats provide 25-30g protein per 100g, contain all essential amino acids, and are highly digestible. Lean cuts reduce fat intake (helpful for overweight dogs).
How to feed: 4-8 oz daily for a 50 lb dog. Rotate proteins (chicken one week, beef the next) for nutrient variety.
4. Fatty Fish
Best options: Sardines, mackerel, salmon, herring.
Why they're excellent: Fish provides 20-25g protein per 100g plus omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA) that reduce inflammation and support brain, heart, and joint health.
How to feed: 2-3 oz of whole fish 3-4x per week for a 50 lb dog. Choose wild-caught when possible. Canned sardines (in water, no salt) are convenient.
5. Dairy (Plain Yogurt, Cottage Cheese)
Why it's good: Plain Greek yogurt and cottage cheese provide 10-11g protein per 100g, are easily digestible, and contain probiotics that support gut health.
How to feed: 2-4 tablespoons daily for a 50 lb dog. Choose plain, unsweetened varieties. Avoid if your dog is lactose intolerant.
Protein-Rich Whole Foods: Serving Guide
| Food | Protein per 100g | Serving (50 lb dog) |
|---|---|---|
| Whole eggs | 13g per egg | 1-2 eggs daily |
| Chicken liver | 20-25g | 2-4 oz, 2-3x/week |
| Chicken breast | 30g | 4-8 oz daily |
| Lean ground beef | 26g | 4-8 oz daily |
| Sardines (canned) | 25g | 2-3 oz, 3-4x/week |
| Salmon | 25g | 3-4 oz, 2-3x/week |
| Greek yogurt (plain) | 10g | 2-4 tbsp daily |
| Cottage cheese | 11g | 2-4 tbsp daily |
Understanding Meat Meals in Dog Food
If you're feeding commercial kibble, you'll see "meat meal" on ingredient lists. Here's what it means.
What Is Meat Meal?
Meat meal is meat that's been rendered—cooked at high heat (250-300°F) to remove moisture and fat, then ground into a powder. It's a concentrated protein source (60-65% protein vs. 18-20% in fresh meat).
Pros and Cons:
Pros:
- Concentrated protein—small amounts provide significant protein
- Shelf-stable—doesn't spoil like fresh meat
- Cost-effective for manufacturers
Cons:
- Heat damage reduces digestibility and amino acid availability
- Quality varies wildly—some meals use low-quality by-products
- Processing removes or degrades vitamins and beneficial fats
Named Meals vs. Generic Meals:
| Type | Example | Quality |
|---|---|---|
| Named meat meal | Chicken meal, salmon meal, lamb meal | Better—specific animal source |
| Generic meat meal | Meat meal, poultry meal, fish meal | Moderate—unknown source |
| By-product meal | Meat and bone meal, poultry by-product meal | Lower—can include low-quality parts |
What to look for: Foods that list whole meat (chicken, beef) as the first ingredient and a named meat meal (chicken meal) as the second or third ingredient. This provides both fresh and concentrated protein.
Can Dogs Eat Protein Powder?
Technically yes—but it's not ideal, and many protein powders are dangerous.
Safe Protein Powders (in moderation):
- Plain whey protein isolate — Unflavored, unsweetened, no additives
- Plain egg white protein — Pure protein, no fillers
Dangerous Protein Powders (NEVER give to dogs):
- Flavored protein powders — Often contain xylitol (artificial sweetener that's toxic to dogs)
- Pre-workout or mass-gainer formulas — Contain stimulants (caffeine, taurine), creatine, and other additives
- Protein powders with added vitamins/minerals — Can cause nutrient imbalances
Why Whole Foods Are Better:
Protein powder is an isolated nutrient. Whole foods provide protein plus vitamins, minerals, healthy fats, and enzymes that support digestion and absorption.
Instead of protein powder, add:
- Cooked eggs (complete protein, perfect amino acid profile)
- Lean chicken or turkey
- Sardines or mackerel
- Plain Greek yogurt
- Cottage cheese
These provide more nutrition per serving than isolated protein powder—and they're species-appropriate.
Plant Protein for Dogs: What You Need to Know
Dogs can digest plant protein, but they're optimized for animal protein. Here's what the science shows.
Why Plant Protein Is Less Ideal:
- Incomplete amino acid profiles — Most plant proteins lack one or more essential amino acids. Exceptions: quinoa, soy (but soy has other concerns).
- Lower digestibility — Dogs lack enzymes (cellulase) to break down plant cell walls efficiently. Bioavailability is 60-75% vs. 85-95% for animal protein.
- Anti-nutritional factors — Legumes (peas, lentils) contain lectins and phytates that reduce mineral absorption.
- High carbohydrate load — Plant proteins come with starches that some dogs don't tolerate well.
When Plant Protein Makes Sense:
- Supplemental fiber and nutrients — Small amounts of lentils, chickpeas, or quinoa add variety
- Food allergies — Dogs allergic to all animal proteins (rare) may need plant-based diets under veterinary supervision
- Owner preference — Some owners choose plant-based for ethical reasons (though this requires careful formulation)
Best Plant Proteins (if using):
| Source | Protein Content | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Quinoa | 4g per 100g cooked | Complete amino acid profile (rare for plants) |
| Lentils | 9g per 100g cooked | High fiber, moderate protein |
| Chickpeas | 8g per 100g cooked | Good fiber, moderate protein |
| Pumpkin seeds | 19g per 100g | High protein, but high fat too |
Best approach: Use animal protein as the foundation (70-80% of protein intake) and supplement with plant proteins for fiber and variety (20-30%).
Protein Needs for Different Life Stages
Puppies
Needs: 25-30% protein from high-quality sources.
Why: Rapid growth, tissue development, immune system building.
Best sources: Eggs, organ meats (small amounts), lean poultry, fish, yogurt.
Special consideration for large breeds: Large breed puppies need controlled calcium and phosphorus to prevent developmental orthopedic disease. Choose large breed puppy formulas—they have appropriate mineral ratios.
Adult Dogs
Needs: 25-30% protein for moderately active dogs, 30-40% for working/athletic dogs.
Why: Maintains muscle mass, supports metabolism, provides energy.
Best sources: Variety of animal proteins—rotate between chicken, beef, fish, eggs, organs.
Senior Dogs
Needs: 25-30% protein, possibly higher (30-35%) to combat muscle loss.
Why: Senior dogs lose muscle mass (sarcopenia) as they age. Higher protein helps maintain muscle, organ function, and immune health.
Best sources: Easily digestible proteins—eggs, fish, lean poultry, organ meats, bone broth.
Myth: Senior Dogs Need Less Protein. This outdated belief came from fears that protein harms kidneys. Modern research shows protein doesn't cause kidney disease in healthy dogs. Senior dogs actually need more high-quality protein to maintain health. Only dogs with diagnosed kidney disease need veterinary-managed protein restriction.
Pregnant and Nursing Dogs
Needs: 28-35% protein.
Why: Fetal development, milk production, maternal recovery.
Best sources: Nutrient-dense proteins—organ meats, eggs, fish, lean meats. Increase feeding frequency (3-4 small meals daily).
Signs Your Dog Isn't Getting Enough Protein
Protein deficiency is rare in dogs fed commercial diets, but it can happen with homemade diets, poor-quality foods, or digestive issues.
Signs of Inadequate Protein:
- Muscle wasting or weakness — Especially in senior dogs
- Dull, brittle coat or excessive shedding — Protein is needed for hair growth
- Slow wound healing — Protein is essential for tissue repair
- Frequent infections — Weakened immune function
- Low energy or lethargy — Protein provides energy and metabolic support
- Stunted growth in puppies — Inadequate protein slows development
- Edema (swelling) — Severe protein deficiency causes fluid retention
If you see these signs: Check your dog's food label (is protein above 25%?), evaluate protein quality (are the first 2-3 ingredients animal proteins?), and consult your vet to rule out malabsorption or digestive issues.
Can Too Much Protein Harm Dogs?
For healthy dogs, excess protein is generally not harmful. The body uses it for energy or excretes nitrogen through urine.
When High Protein Can Be Problematic:
- Existing kidney disease — Dogs with compromised kidneys may benefit from moderate protein restriction (consult your vet)
- Severe liver disease — Protein metabolism can stress a failing liver (rare, requires vet management)
- Imbalanced diet — All protein, no fiber or healthy fats causes digestive upset
Healthy Dogs Can Safely Consume:
- 30-50% protein diets without issues
- Working and athletic dogs often thrive on 40%+ protein
- Very high protein (60%+) is unnecessary and may cause loose stools or increased thirst—but it's not dangerous
The real concern isn't too much protein—it's wrong protein sources:
- Heavily processed proteins create more metabolic waste
- Low-quality proteins lack essential amino acids
- Imbalanced homemade diets cause nutrient deficiencies
Bottom line: 25-30% high-quality protein beats 40% low-quality protein every time. Focus on quality over quantity.
Choosing High-Quality Protein: What to Look For
Reading Dog Food Labels:
- Check the first 5 ingredients — At least 2-3 should be animal proteins (chicken, beef, salmon, chicken meal)
- Look for named protein sources — "Chicken" and "chicken meal" are better than "meat" and "poultry meal"
- Calculate dry matter protein — Should be 25-30% minimum
- Avoid generic meals — "Meat meal," "poultry by-product meal," "meat and bone meal" are low quality
- Check for whole foods — Fresh meat, eggs, fish listed early in ingredients
For Whole-Food Feeding:
- Aim for 40-60% of calories from protein (roughly 4-8 oz meat/fish per day for a 50 lb dog)
- Rotate protein sources — Chicken, beef, fish, eggs, organs throughout the week
- Include organ meats 1-2x per week — Liver, kidney, heart (5-10% of diet)
- Add eggs regularly — 1-2 whole eggs daily provides perfect amino acids
- Balance with vegetables and healthy fats — Protein shouldn't be 100% of the diet
Minimally Processed Protein: Why It Matters
Processing degrades protein quality. The less heat and pressure applied, the better the protein retains its nutritional value.
| Processing Level | Examples | Protein Quality |
|---|---|---|
| Fresh/frozen | Raw or lightly cooked meat, eggs, fish | Excellent — minimal nutrient loss |
| Freeze-dried | Freeze-dried raw food, treats | Very good — low heat, retains nutrients |
| Dehydrated | Air-dried, low-temp dehydrated food | Good — gentle processing |
| Gently cooked | Slow-cooked fresh food, homemade meals | Moderate — some nutrient loss |
| Extruded kibble | Most dry dog food | Moderate — high heat damages protein |
| Rendered meals | Meat meals, by-product meals | Lower — extreme heat, pressure |
Best approach: Choose the least processed protein your budget and lifestyle allow. Fresh, frozen, or freeze-dried foods provide the highest-quality protein.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much protein do dogs need?
Adult dogs need a minimum of 18% protein in their diet (AAFCO standard), but optimal amounts are higher. Active adult dogs: 25-30% protein supports muscle maintenance and energy. Puppies: 22-28% protein (AAFCO minimum: 22.5%) for growth and development. Senior dogs: 25-30% protein helps maintain muscle mass (contrary to old beliefs about reducing protein). Working/athletic dogs: 30-40% protein for muscle recovery and performance. These percentages refer to dry matter basis—the protein content after removing moisture. Quality matters as much as quantity. Dogs fed high-quality, bioavailable protein (organ meats, muscle meat, fish) thrive on moderate amounts. Dogs fed low-quality protein (heavily processed meals, plant proteins) may need higher amounts to meet amino acid requirements.
What is high-quality protein for dogs?
High-quality protein is easily digestible and contains all essential amino acids in proper ratios. Quality indicators include digestibility (how much the dog can absorb—measured as biological value), amino acid profile (contains all 10 essential amino acids dogs need), bioavailability (nutrients are in forms the body can use), and minimal processing (less heat damage, fewer denatured proteins). Best sources ranked by quality: whole eggs (biological value: 100—the gold standard), organ meats (liver, kidney, heart—90-95 biological value), muscle meats (chicken, beef, fish—85-90), and whole fish (sardines, mackerel—85-90). Lower quality sources: meat meals and by-product meals (70-80—heavily processed, nutrient loss), plant proteins (soy, pea protein—60-75, missing or low in some essential amino acids), and rendered proteins (generic meat meal, poultry by-products—quality varies widely).
Can dogs eat protein powder or whey protein?
Dogs can eat plain whey protein in small amounts, but it's not ideal. Whey protein isolate (unflavored, unsweetened) is safe in moderation and provides complete amino acids, but most dogs don't need protein powder—whole foods are better. Avoid flavored protein powders (contain artificial sweeteners like xylitol, which is toxic to dogs), pre-workout or mass-gainer formulas (contain stimulants, creatine, other additives), and protein powders with added vitamins/minerals (can cause imbalances). If you want to boost protein, use whole-food sources: cooked eggs, lean chicken or turkey, sardines or mackerel, plain Greek yogurt, or cottage cheese. These provide protein plus vitamins, minerals, and beneficial fats that isolated protein powder lacks. Protein powder is a processed supplement designed for humans—dogs benefit more from species-appropriate whole foods.
What are the best high-protein foods for dogs?
The best high-protein foods are minimally processed, easily digestible, and nutrient-dense. Top choices: Eggs (13g protein per large egg, 100% bioavailable, contains all essential amino acids), organ meats like liver, kidney, heart (20-25g protein per 100g, extremely nutrient-dense, highly digestible), lean muscle meats including chicken breast, turkey, lean beef (25-30g protein per 100g), fatty fish such as sardines, mackerel, salmon (20-25g protein per 100g plus omega-3s), plain Greek yogurt (10g protein per 100g, contains probiotics), and cottage cheese (11g protein per 100g, easily digestible). Serving sizes for a 50 lb dog: 1-2 whole eggs daily, 2-4 oz organ meats 2-3x per week, 4-8 oz muscle meat daily, 2-3 oz fish 3-4x per week. These whole-food proteins provide not just amino acids, but vitamins, minerals, healthy fats, and bioavailable nutrients that processed proteins lack.
Is plant protein good for dogs?
Plant proteins can supplement a dog's diet but shouldn't be the primary protein source. Dogs are facultative carnivores—they can digest plant matter but are optimized for animal protein. Limitations of plant proteins: incomplete amino acid profiles (most plant proteins are low in one or more essential amino acids), lower digestibility (dogs lack enzymes to fully break down plant cell walls), anti-nutritional factors (lectins, phytates in legumes reduce nutrient absorption), and higher carbohydrate load (comes with starches that some dogs don't tolerate well). Decent plant protein sources for supplementation: lentils (9g protein per 100g cooked), chickpeas (8g protein per 100g), quinoa (4g protein per 100g—one of few complete plant proteins), and pumpkin seeds (19g protein per 100g). Best approach: use animal proteins as the foundation (70-80% of protein intake), supplement with plant proteins for fiber and variety if desired (20-30%). Don't rely on plant-based dog foods unless medically necessary—most dogs thrive on animal protein.
Do senior dogs need less protein?
No—this is a common myth. Senior dogs actually need more protein, not less, to maintain muscle mass and support healthy aging. Research shows senior dogs lose muscle mass (sarcopenia) as they age, and adequate protein helps slow this decline. High-quality protein supports immune function (which weakens with age), aids wound healing and recovery, maintains organ function (especially liver and kidneys), and provides amino acids for neurotransmitter production. Recommended protein for senior dogs: 25-30% of diet (same or higher than adult dogs), from high-quality, easily digestible sources. The myth about reducing protein came from outdated beliefs that protein harms kidneys. Modern research shows protein doesn't cause kidney disease in healthy dogs. Dogs with existing kidney disease need veterinary management—but even then, moderate high-quality protein is better than low-quality protein. Best proteins for senior dogs: eggs (easy to digest), organ meats (nutrient-dense), fish (omega-3s reduce inflammation), lean poultry, and bone broth (provides amino acids in highly absorbable form).
What is the difference between meat and meat meal in dog food?
Meat and meat meal are different in processing, moisture content, and protein concentration. Meat (chicken, beef, lamb) is fresh or frozen muscle tissue, contains 60-70% water, and provides about 18-20% protein by weight. When cooked during kibble production, water evaporates, so the actual protein contribution is lower than it appears on the ingredients list. Meat meal (chicken meal, beef meal) is meat that's been rendered (cooked at high heat) and dried to remove moisture and fat, contains only 10% water, and provides 60-65% protein by weight. It's a concentrated protein source, but heat processing can damage amino acids and reduce digestibility. Quality varies widely: named meat meals (chicken meal, salmon meal) are better quality than generic meals (meat meal, poultry meal, meat and bone meal). The best approach: Look for whole meat as the first ingredient plus a named meat meal as the second or third ingredient. This provides both fresh protein and concentrated protein. Avoid foods where the first 3-4 ingredients are grains or starches with meat meal buried lower in the list. Better still: choose minimally processed foods (freeze-dried, dehydrated, fresh) that don't require rendering.
How do I know if my dog is getting enough protein?
Signs your dog is getting adequate, high-quality protein include good muscle tone (visible muscle definition, not overweight or underweight), shiny, healthy coat with minimal shedding, strong energy levels appropriate for age and breed, healthy skin (no excessive dryness, flaking, or irritation), good immune function (infrequent illness, quick recovery from minor issues), and healthy appetite and digestion. Signs of inadequate or poor-quality protein: muscle wasting or weakness (especially in senior dogs), dull, brittle coat or excessive shedding, low energy or lethargy, slow wound healing or frequent infections, poor appetite or digestive issues, and stunted growth (in puppies). Check your dog food label: protein should be 25-30% minimum (dry matter basis), the first ingredient should be a named meat source, and at least 2-3 of the first 5 ingredients should be animal proteins. If you're feeding whole foods, aim for 40-60% of calories from protein sources (eggs, meat, fish, organs). If you see signs of protein deficiency despite feeding a high-protein food, the issue may be quality or digestibility—consult your vet and consider switching to higher-quality protein sources.
Can too much protein harm dogs?
For healthy dogs, excess protein is generally not harmful—the body simply uses it for energy or excretes excess nitrogen. However, there are some considerations. Excessive protein can be problematic if: your dog has existing kidney disease (consult your vet—they may recommend moderate protein restriction), the diet is imbalanced (all protein, no fiber or fat causes digestive issues), or protein quality is poor (low digestibility means more waste for kidneys to process). Healthy dogs can safely consume 30-50% protein diets without issues. Working dogs and athletes often thrive on 40%+ protein. The concern isn't the protein itself, but diet balance. Very high-protein diets (60%+) can cause loose stools, increased thirst, and extra kidney workload—but this is rare with normal feeding. The real risk is not too much protein, but wrong protein sources: heavily processed proteins create more metabolic waste, plant-heavy proteins may lack essential amino acids, and imbalanced homemade diets can cause deficiencies. Focus on quality over quantity: 25-30% high-quality protein beats 40% low-quality protein every time.
What protein is best for puppies?
Puppies need high-quality, easily digestible protein for rapid growth and development. AAFCO minimum: 22.5% protein, but optimal is 25-30% from high-quality sources. Best proteins for puppies: whole eggs (perfect amino acid profile, highly digestible), organ meats like liver (nutrient-dense, supports development—give 1-2x per week in small amounts), lean poultry such as chicken, turkey (easily digestible, good amino acid profile), fish including salmon, sardines (omega-3s support brain and eye development), and plain yogurt or cottage cheese (probiotics support gut health). Key considerations for puppy protein: digestibility matters more than quantity—puppies have sensitive digestive systems, variety supports balanced nutrition—rotate protein sources, and avoid overfeeding large breed puppies (excess protein plus excess calories can cause too-rapid growth and joint issues). Feed large breed puppies food formulated for large breed growth—it has controlled calcium and phosphorus to prevent developmental orthopedic disease. For small/medium breeds, high-quality puppy food or fresh whole foods work well. Protein needs decrease slightly after 6 months but remain higher than adult dogs until fully grown (12-24 months depending on breed).